POSITIVE FEEDBACK REVIEW.........
Harmonix combak
as reviewed by Marshall Nack
Adventures with Harmonix accessories: Tuning Spike Bases, Cable Support, Component Footers
"Hey, Sir. You lack substance. You've got great imaging, but,
, where's the beef?" Oy! Perhaps you too have suffered this painful accusation. Perhaps it is still an issue. Well, join the crowd. But wait, here's some very good news: the cure is at hand.
Harmonix RF-900 Tuning Spike Base
The Harmonix Combak Corporation has been making audio tuning accessories for nearly three decades. Their RF 900 Tuning Spike Bases are about the size of a half dollar, made of gold-colored metal with a dimple in the center and a black felt-covered bottomabout what you'd expect for a spike base. They come in sets of four in a little clear plastic box with two pages of instruction in Japanese. Not that there's any secrets to usage. Just slip them under the spike points of your audio gear.
Remember those sexy, seductive recordings by Stan Getz with Astrud and João Gilberto that made Bossa Nova a phenomenon back in the 70s? Well, then you'll recognize Entre Amigos (Chesky 90368-0247-2) falling squarely within that genre. I tend to
Entre Amigos even better than the fondly remembered Getz/Gilberto clichésGetz was a good introduction to this music, but grew to be predictable. His competition is veteran bassist Ron Carter on this CD, who is always doing something interesting. Rosa Passos,
her predecessor Astrud Gilberto, sings in the same breathy Brazilian samba style, but manages to convey the feeling behind the words. She comes across as a mature woman of character, less little girl-like. On most tracks you have an acoustic guitar hard right, another down center played by Rosa, Ron's bass center-left, and percussion center-right. These are simple, but effective arrangements. On track 7, "Por Causa de Voce", only Ron's bass accompanies Rosa. He lays down the chords while she's singing and provides improvisation when she's not, as a guitar or a piano would. He does the job tastefully, without ostentation or cramping Rosa's style, even though the bass EQ is prominent on this CD. The pathos of the song is communicated. Recording quality is very naturalisticno spotlighting, or post-production gimmickry, another good job from Chesky.
I liked Entre Amigos from first listen, even though playback had some problem areas. Ron's bass was almost out of control, too boomy, and flooding into the mid-range. Rosa's bedroom voice sounded
a breathy whisper, a throat voice without the body attached, in a mezzo-soprano range. The guitars and the sax were good, but the percussion seems to follow the beat and sounded
it was thrown in as an afterthought.
Just replacing the metal spike bases that came with my Kharma CRM 3.2 speakers with a set of the Harmonix RF-900 Tuning Spike Bases unexpectedly addressed all of these issues: first, by giving Rosa a normal voice; second, by controlling and tuning Ron's bass; third, by revealing the space. These major improvementsplus many more little things,
unnoticed acoustic cues and nuances, color and subtle timing improvementsmade their appearance through the tuning effects of the RF-900. Surprisingly, the missing "beef" also began to appear. "Just a minute", I hear you say, "How could all this happen from the mere substitution of spike bases?"
According to their brochures, Harmonix engineers began their R & D by studying the resonance characteristics of fine violins in order to "understand how beautiful sound is produced in the first place." They "found that resonance in a violin is perfectly balanced in one frequency."
When you excite one of its strings, the body of the violin doesn't just make the sound louder, it tunes the sound to carefully selected frequencies, and then amplifies it. The engineers applied this to audio products to "eliminate unwanted resonance frequencies to achieve
pure, distortion-free reproduction," through tuning. Theoretically, if you tune resonances and remove noise in an audio system, especially treble noise, the sound you are left with is completely integral with the note. The resulting clean and pure notes are more musically centered, and sound
they are played more accurately. Instrumental lines become easy to follow. It sounds so simple, doesn't it? Tuning your system to imitate the way a violin controls resonance makes such good common sense, doesn't it? Ladies and gentlemen, it took a little while to recognize it, but that is what I heard the RF-900 do.
You will find the treble less prominent, less aggressive and, indeed, more pure. You may not notice that the low-end is subtly reduced, but you will be aware that it is less boomy and its attack has acquired a point, giving it much better articulation. You will definitely notice enhanced weight and fullness. What happened was the non-musical artifacts, the noise, was removed from the frequency extremes and showed up as a commensurate dose of richness in the upper bass through the mid band: this is the missing "beef." Without non-musical artifacts cluttering the stage, the musical details of the presentation are abundant.
Let's get back to Entre Amigos. I should also mention that I heard at least as much of the incidental sounds,
keys flapping, valves opening and closing and chairs scraping, as before. Here's a sampling of some of the things that surfaced after the RF-900 were put in. The sax on "Desafinado" (track 3) now has two distinct components, the note and the breath blowing through the mouthpiece. Both parts emanate from the same source and I can focus my attention on either. I'm used to hearing them mixed together, inseparable, with the breathiness dominant and compromising the note. And now I notice the breathiness I'm used to hearing in Rosa's voice is reduced or eliminated, and what's left of it is now integral with her voice,
what happened with the sax. Anytime breathiness is reduced and tone is enhanced is a good thing. Some curiosities: Rosa's voice is now a large sound source, larger than the guitars, and more forward, although she shares their acoustic space; the drum kit in the far right of the stage has receded. It actually sounds too far away. These are artifacts, just data, revealing how the session was recorded.
Speaker spikes first
Without question the biggest bang for the buck came from replacing the spike bases under the speakers with RF-900, but I also found them good under individual components and even under the rack itself. Here's how I decorated my phono pre-amp, which is already so massively tweaked out as to be a source of concern by visitors. First, it's on the Mapleshade Rack of Samson, with shelves made from solid maple wood and uprights made from heavy steel rods. The bottom end of those steel rods terminates in Mapleshade brass cone pointsfirst application for the RF-900s. The power supply for the phono pre-amp is on the top shelf of the Rack of Samson, on Walker Audio Valid Pointssecond application. The phono pre-amp main chassis is alongside the power supply, but has an extra four-inch thick maple block and Mapleshade brass conepoints and Isoblocks under itthird point of application. Three sets of RF-900 went in.
I was listening to Handel's Water Musick, one of those late, great Harmonia Mundi LPs (HMU 7010) recorded by Peter McGrath in 1987. Nicholas McGegan and his Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra give a stylish, period instrument performance, which is really the only way the work should be done, the way His Majesty must have heard it circa 1715, while disporting himself on the River Thames. As I've noted elsewhere, this LP has amazing detail and focus, and throws a super dimensional soundstage. Well, musical focus and weight certainly improved, but best of all was the repair work done on string tone. Individual players' skills improved before your eyes (or ears). The melody made more sense as it was passed among each section, and the tune itself became so much more engrossing.
Good performances became better; the converse of that was also true. Lackluster or outright bad performances only became easier to critique. Yes, there is a degree of euphony going on in the beautification of the sound, with aspects similar to what you might get from a really good cable that favors the romantic side. But if the guys aren't playing well, it'll still gonna sound
a bad performance. The RF-900 can't fix a bad performance. They make it sound sweeter, but nothing will correct an out of tune note.
And who's to say that the "dirty" sound of most playback systems is any truer than the tuned sound of a "Harmonized" system? The instruments at the recording venue were tuned, right? When you playback the recording and it sounds noisywhere did that come from? Myself, I don't think about it too much. Like any other audiophile tweakeither they work or they don't.
Another example: I was going back and forth between two versions of a certain manufacturer's top-of-the-line speaker cable, the current offering and a new, upgraded one. My principal reservations about the current version were its grainy texture and a certain tonal thinness. The extra $500 for the new one got you a cable that addressed these issues, along with slightly better performance just about everywhere else, too. I was liking it. One night I came home from work and found two sets of the RF-900 waiting in the mailbox. I promptly deployed them under components on my Solid Tech Rack of Silence. You guessed it; the sound was so improved, it took several minutes to remember that I was listening to the current speaker cable. Along with remedying thinness, I forgot to mention that the RF-900 alleviates graininess.
